With training camps open, time to grade every NFL team's offseason – just two get A's
The NFL offseason, such as it is, officially ends today as the remainder of the league's 32 teams kick off their training camps. Or, as Chargers coach Jim Harbaugh said after his team was the first to fully report last week: "It's being reborn. It's the start of the year. Some would think it's January 1st. Those espoused to Catholicism, Christianity would think it's the birth of Christ. Us in football, it's the first day of training camp." As far as we know, it's not New Year's Day, nor are Three Wise Men set to report to Bethlehem. But we get it, Coach. Back to the football. And while positional battles, injuries and the constant churn of league-wide transactions will continue to impact every club's roster and depth chart, issuing report cards for each team's showing since the 2024 season ended can no longer wait now that squads have essentially taken their full shapes for the upcoming campaign. So, without further ado, here are each team's grades for their performances off the field over the past few months: They might have won the offseason the minute they hired highly, highly regarded Ben Johnson as their head coach, not only adding an offensive wunderkind but damaging the rival Lions in the process given the impact he'd had on their attack, which ranked in the top five each of the past three seasons. Recently extended GM Ryan Poles made a series of other moves to not only help Johnson but also boost second-year QB Caleb Williams, who had an uneven rookie season (to put it mildly). Poles buttressed the blocking by trading for Gs Joe Thuney, an All-Pro, and Jonah Jackson before signing highly regarded C Drew Dalman. The draft also brought two new toys for Williams, TE Colston Loveland and WR Luther Burden plus, maybe, his next left tackle (Ozzy Trapilo). Poles also put in work on the defensive side, extending LB T.J. Edwards for two years, signing two-time Pro Bowler Grady Jarrett and up-and-coming pass rusher Dayo Odeyingbo before snagging DL Shemar Turner in the draft's second round. Little room for further excuses here, though Johnson and Poles now seem to have far more security than the players. The return of Mike Vrabel to Foxborough as this team's new head coach should have the broadest impact on this franchise now and well into the future – and is also the stroke that should be the primary accelerant to second-year QB Drake Maye's career. But the Pats also did plenty from a roster standpoint to bulwark the league's worst offense – notably earmarking its first draft four picks to that side of the ball. First-round OT Will Campbell and second-round RB TreVeyon Henderson are both expected to immediately have major roles. New WR Stefon Diggs and RT Morgan Moses are veteran additions and somewhat damaged goods – both coming off knee surgery – but benefit Maye. Expect a big jump defensively after most of the team's copious free agent budget went there in order to sign DT Milton Williams (4 years, $104 million), considered perhaps the crown jewel of a thin free agent crop. LB Robert Spillane, OLB Harold Landry and DB Carlton Davis III all got three-year deals worth more than $130 million in sum – a lot to shell out for a trio with all of one Pro Bowl nod on their collective résumés. The return of DT Christian Barmore, who was sidelined by blood clots last season, is a bonus. If Maye continues along his trajectory, a team that won four games in 2024 could easily double that total. Last week was the cherry on top of Phase One of their cultural reset, WR Garrett Wilson and CB Sauce Gardner signing four-year extensions that not onlysolidify the roster's foundation but underscore the philosophical buy-inno-frills rookie coach Aaron Glenn is getting before even working a game. Those deals followed what seemed like a strong draft anchored by first-round RT Armand Membou and second-round TE Mason Taylor, who should both be Week 1 starters while adding further steel to this club's backbone. New QB1 Justin Fields, tabbed to replace Aaron Rodgers after Glenn put an end to that era (error?), represented new GM Darren Mougey's biggest foray into free agency and will eitherput a wedge in the team's revolving door behind centeror put them back in the market for a passer in what should be a strong 2026 draft at the position. CB D.J. Reed will be missed. As has been the case with nearly every reigning champion during the salary cap portion of the Super Bowl era, you can't keep everyone. And while the Eagles will return their offense nearly intact – it should be fine sans RG Mekhi Becton – the defense took some hits. Among the departed: Williams, OLB Josh Sweat, DBs Darius Slay and C.J. Gardner-Johnson and retired DE Brandon Graham. However EVP/GM Howie Roseman, who always seems ready for what's next, issued smart raisesto RB Saquon Barkley and RT Lane Johnson, got new deals done for LB Zack Baun and C Cam Jurgens and, thanks to his drafting acumen, the defense appears backfilled by capable replacements, though there's no sugarcoating the loss of depth. (However Roseman did bring in a lot of accomplished veterans at low cost, a list that includes LBs Azeez Ojulari and Josh Uche, CB Adoree' Jackson, TE Harrison Bryant and RB AJ Dillon.) Versatile first-round LB Jihaad Campbell, who likely wouldn't have fallen to the 31st overall pick had his shoulder been healthy, could also make up some of the shortfall. And watch out for second-round S Andrew Mukuba. In other good news, coach Nick Sirianni got an extension …as did the "Tush Push,"perhaps partially thanks to a late shove from former pusher Jason Kelce to the league's owners. AFC North champs the past two seasons, they're nicely set up to make another strong Super Bowl push – getting Pro Bowl LT Ronnie Stanley re-signed while adding accomplished veterans such as WR DeAndre Hopkins and CB Jaire Alexander. Their top two draft picks, S Malaki Starks and OLB Mike Green, could make instant impacts. A tight cap could make anything further on the personnel side a challenge, but an extension needs to get done fairly soon for All-Pro QB Lamar Jackson – he carries a prohibitive $74.5 million cap hit in 2026 and '27 – and then new deals for young core players such as S Kyle Hamilton, C Tyler Linderbaum and TE Isaiah Likely should follow. Also, it remains to be seen what Baltimore gets from whomever replacesdisgraced former K Justin Tucker, who was released last month. A team that made a surprising playoff run in 2024behind rookie QB Bo Nixcould be poised to take the next step. Denver drafted DB Jahdae Barron and RB RJ Harvey – both could play a ton of snaps as rookies – and took a targeted approach to free agency, which brought TE Evan Engram, RB J.K. Dobbins, LB Dre Greenlaw and S Talanoa Hufanga … though all of those veterans come with extensive injuries in their backgrounds. Yet if half of them pan out, Sean Payton's team could challenge K.C. for AFC West supremacy. You wouldn't think a cemented dynasty would have this productive an offseason or this much financial flexibility – and QB Patrick Mahomes deserves more credit on that front given his ongoing willingness to restructure his contract and allocate money elsewhere. And while not everyone will be back, notably Thuney and S Justin Reid, the team managed to extend G Trey Smith and DE George Karlaftis, re-signed LB Nick Bolton, WRs Hollywood Brown and JuJu Smith-Schuster and RB Kareem Hunt. GM Brett Veach was also able to add OT Jaylon Moore and CB Kristian Fulton. TE Travis Kelce will, at minimum, play out the final year of his contract, and WR Rashee Rice returns after last year's season-ending knee injury − though he could miss the early part of the season if the NFL hands down a suspension in theaftermath of his legal issues being resolved. The defense was heavily augmented by the draft, but the spotlight will be on first-round OT Josh Simmons who, along with Moore, will be vying to solidify the new-look left side of a line thatfailed the team during its Super Bowl 59 three-peat bid. It's a fascinating mix of stability and churn for a team that's only missed the Super Bowl once in the past six seasons. Yet the O-line does remain something of a question aside from Smith and C Creed Humphrey. If HC Brian Daboll and GM Joe Schoen are truly on the hot seat … gonna be interesting. First-round QB Jaxson Dart is clearly the future here, but will Daboll have the luxury of developing him in a redshirt manner after Schoen brought in veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston? How much will the secondary benefit after New York invested three years and nearly $100 million collectively for S Jevon Holland and CB Paulson Adebo? (Maybe a lot with No. 3 overall pick Abdul Carter, Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux rushing quarterbacks.) A draft that brought Carter, Dart and RB Cam Skattebo could pay off handsomely … whether it's for this front office or the next one. A team that unexpectedly won 10 games and fell a tiebreaker short of postseason in 2024, Mike Macdonald's first as head coach, nevertheless took something of a sledgehammer to the top of its roster. Gone are QB Geno Smith and WRs DK Metcalf and Tyler Lockett, among others. In are Pro Bowl QB Sam Darnold, WR Cooper Kupp and DE DeMarcus Lawrence, among others. The trades of Smith and Metcalf paved the way for a big-time draft that brought OL Grey Zabel, S Nick Emmanwori, TE Elijah Arroyo and highly intriguing third-round QB Jalen Milroe. Should be fascinating to see how a team more tailored to Macdonald's philosophy coalesces. Given QB Cam Ward was the top pick of this year's draft, there's been remarkably little national buzz around the player or his new team. And maybe that's not such a bad thing – ask the 2024 Bears. Ward has decent weaponry around him, and rookie GM Mike Borgonzi prepared for his arrival by securing veteran G Kevin Zeitler and LT Dan Moore in free agency. And now it's undoubtedly full speed ahead with Ward following Monday's news that last year's starter, Will Levis,will miss the 2025 seasonafter opting to undergo shoulder surgery. Heavy defensive emphasis, GM Monti Ossenfort taking DT Walter Nolen and highly regarded CB Will Johnson with his first two draft picks after plucking Sweat from the champion Eagles during free agency. Trey McBride got a deal that briefly made him the league's best paid-tight end at $19 million annually. Will it be enough to vault a team that doubled its win total to eight last season into the playoffs? If WR Marvin Harrison Jr. has improved as much as he and the team think, maybe. Is their interminable Super Bowl quest going over the top? Buffalo's biggest move was re-signing QB Josh Allen to a six-year, $330 million extension – which is actually below market value at $55 million annually. Securing the reigning league MVP is a huge plus, and GM Brandon Beane also reinvested heavily elsewhere in his roster (DE Greg Rousseau, WR Khalil Shakir, LB Terrel Bernard, CB Christian Benford). The team seems confident the development of WR Keon Coleman, addition of WR Josh Palmer and return to health by TE Dalton Kincaid can take the passing game up a notch. But will a generally conservative reliance on continuity be enough? Also, first-round CB Maxwell Hairston is dealing with legal issues, and DE Joey Bosa (calf) is already coping with an injury. They made a splash – by Wisconsin standards – after taking Matthew Golden in the first round of the draft, breaking a 23-year streak when they'd avoided Round 1 wideouts. If he can establish himself as the No. 1 receiver, much as HC Matt LaFleur hates that label, this offense could reach a new level. GM Brian Gutekunst made other significant, if less noted, moves, extending OL Zach Tom and bringing in free agent G Aaron Banks and CB Nate Hobbs, all on four-year contracts. Hobbs basically replaces now-departed Alexander. After the offense regressed around second-year QB C.J. Stroud in 2024, a team that's won the past two AFC South crowns should probably be given credit for not resting on its laurels, largely remaking the O-line and receiver room while firing coordinator Bobby Slowik, who was taking head coach interviews just a year ago. It remains to be seen how Stroud fares with new play caller Nick Caley or behind a line that could have a different player in every spot but right tackle compared to the combinations Houston used in last season's playoffs. But with newly acquired vets like WR Christian Kirk and Gardner-Johnson plus a nice haul of rookies – OL Aireontae Ersery, WRs Jayden Higgins and Jaylin Noel – and perhaps six picks in the first three rounds of next year's draft, it's easy to understand GM Nick Caserio's logic. And he gets extra points for moving quickly to extend All-Pro CB Derek Stingley Jr. With the bold move up to get WR/CB Travis Hunter, rookie GM James Gladstone is banking on this as a transformative offseason that's potentially netted a new face of the franchise. Whether Hunter, who cost the Jags their second-rounder this year and a first in 2026, can effectively gain this team a roster spot or even consistently be a major presence on both sides of the ball game in and game out remains to be seen. His impact will also be largely dictated by the health of QB Trevor Lawrence, who underwent surgery on his non-throwing shoulder and is adapting to yet another head coach with rookie Liam Coen now in the post. But Lawrence should enjoy upgraded protection after Gladstone signed free agent OL Patrick Mekari and Robert Hainsey to three-year deals. But the organization really needs Coen, Hunter, WR Brian Thomas Jr. and maybe even new deep threat Dyami Brown to help the No. 1 pick of the 2021 draft blossom into the superstar he was projected to be coming out of Clemson. You're forgiven if you thought a team that traded out of the first round basically spent the offseason swapping out Kupp for Davante Adams and tweaking its O-line. But GM Les Snead also gotnew deals done for QB Matthew Staffordand LT Alaric Jackson while adding NT Poona Ford to an ascending defense. Second-round TE Terrance Ferguson could quickly add a new offensive dimension. HC Kevin O'Connell and GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah both got deserved extensions in the wake of a surprising 14-win season and busily did what they could to put new QB1 J.J. McCarthy into an optimal situation as he prepares to take his first regular-season snaps following a rookie year completely lost to a knee injury. That's meant adding OL Will Fries, Ryan Kelly and first-rounder Donovan Jackson plus re-signing RB Aaron Jones. McCarthy should also benefit from a play-making defense reinforced by veteran DTs Jonathan Allen and Javon Hargrave plus the retention of S Harrison Smith and fast-improving CB Byron Murphy. But this whole thing might be undone if the decision to part with Darnold proves a mistake. Ultimately, this season will be judged by whether a team nearly a decade removed from its last playoff win made the right call at quarterback … something it hasn't done for some time. But after failing to convince Fields, who was benched for Wilson last season, to re-sign or pry Stafford loose from the Rams, per reports, coachMike Tomlin and GM Omar Khan settled on Rodgers– for what's likely a one-year rental – rather than roll the dice on a rookie passer in a draft that seemed thin on QB prospects. Otherwise? In are Metcalf, CBs Jalen Ramsey and Slay and TE Jonnu Smith. Out are WR George Pickens, RB Najee Harris and S Minkah Fitzpatrick. For better or worse, soon-to-be 31-year-oldOLB T.J. Watt just landed an extensionaveraging $41 million, meaning he's now the league's best-compensated non-QB for the next five minutes. A seemingly strong draft class headlined by DL Derrick Harmon and RB Kaleb Johnson effectively gets additional boosts from 2024 first-round RT Troy Fautanu and speedy third-round WR Roman Wilson, who made one appearance apiece as rookies. Will all that be enough to win more than 10 games and reach the divisional round of postseason? We don't have to tell you to stay tuned. A team that values stability as much as any certainly maintained it, extending the contracts of GM Jason Licht and coach Todd Bowles as the organization eyes a fifth straight NFC South crown. WR Chris Godwin and LB Lavonte David are also back. OLB Haason Reddick and rookie WR Emeka Egbuka are probably the most prominent newcomers, though the draft brought quite a few defensive reinforcements. LT Tristan Wirfs (knee surgery) will miss the start of the season, but Godwin is hoping his ankle is ready to go for Week 1. Welp, it's never dull in Big D. The Cowboys began 2025 with thefairly surprising choice of naming Brian Schottenheimerto his first head coaching gig – he replaced Mike McCarthy – and his tenure seems to be off to a good start in the locker room. It helps to haveQB Dak Prescott fully recoveredfrom the hamstring injury that cut his 2024 season short. There's also beenample buzz following the trade with Pittsburgh for Pickens. Issues certainly remain − though,despite owner Jerry Jones' rhetoric, expect DE Micah Parsons to soon become the league's next highest-paid non-quarterback. Figuring out if they have an effective runner to replace departed RB Rico Dowdle, whether Joe Milton III is potentially ready to fill in for Prescott and if recently fined CB Trevon Diggs can get back into the team's good graces could actually be more difficult answers to find. There's little doubt they should be more competitive on the heels of a 4-13 campaign. Yet with a soon-to-be 74-year-old coach in Pete Carroll and soon-to-be 35-year-old QB Geno Smith, it all feels very … interim? The team locked up DE Maxx Crosby through the 2029 season. But All-Pro TE Brock Bowers feels like the only other cornerstone right now, though rookie GM John Spytek certainly hopes he found more in RB Ashton Jeanty, WR Jack Bech and others in what could be a strong draft class. The uncertain status of DT Christian Wilkins (foot surgery), signed to a four-year, $110 million deal a year ago, remains a concern. Some bills came due, literally and figuratively. Primarily,Brock Purdy finally became eligibleto come off the NFL's version of quarterback welfare, signing a five-year, $265 million extension. Two of the team's other linchpins, TE George Kittle and LB Fred Warner, also inked new deals. But there were unavoidable ripple effects, perhaps most notably the trade of WR Deebo Samuel. The defense was also stripped of several former mainstays, including Greenlaw, Hufanga, DE Leonard Floyd, CB Charvarius Ward, and DTs Hargrave and Maliek Collins. Former Jets coach Robert Saleh is back to run the unit but will have to try and revive it with a lot of new players after GM George Lynch devoted his first five 2025 draft picks to the defensive side of the ball before trading for DE Bryce Huff. On the health front,All-Pros Christian McCaffreyand Trent Williams seem ready to return, but WRs Brandon Aiyuk and Ricky Pearsall are currently on the PUP list. Given QB Jayden Danielsenters his second seasonas a bona fide MVP candidate, you want to commend a team that's already going for it byadding veterans like OLB Von Miller. And retaining leaders like LB Bobby Wagner, TE Zach Ertz and QB2 Marcus Mariota should only pay current and future dividends. Rookies Josh Conerly and Trey Amos should contribute heavily early and often. Yet it's worth asking if Washington will ultimately be happywith its trades for Samuel, who's a touch volatile and often banged up, and LT Laremy Tunsil, who led the NFL with 19 penalties in 2024 (12 of them false starts). Also, three years and $45 million for DL Javon Kinlaw? And it probably shouldn't have taken this longto reach a financial agreement with WR Terry McLaurin, who's been a good soldier here long before the team got good … or even respectable. Derek Carr recently retired. Former All-Pro Ryan Ramczyk officially retired. The longtime 4-3 base defense was retired.Tyrann Mathieu juuust retired. At least the team's often tenuous cap situation improved. Reid, OLB Chase Young and TE Juwan Johnson are all good players who signed three-year deals. Rookies Kelvin Banks, Tyler Shough and Vernon Broughton, might be, too. However expectations for this season should be decidedly in check. Perhaps it's all ultimately for the best if Shough turns out to be the starting quarterback for rookie HC Kellen Moore much sooner than initially expected. Though they drafted WR Tetairoa McMillan with the eighth pick of the first round, the general lack of tinkering with the offense is indicative of how they feel about QB Bryce Young's progress last year and the pieces around him. The return of DE Derrick Brown, who missed all but one game in 2024 with a knee injury, should be the best news for a defense that gave up the most points and yards in the league last season. But GM Dan Morgan also paid up to improve that side of the ball, signing S Tre'von Moehrig and DTs Tershawn Wharton to three-year deals averaging at least $15 million after missing out on ex-Eagle Milton Williams. CB Jaycee Horn also got a huge extension. OLB Jadeveon Clowney was released in May, and lingering concussion issues led to LB Josey Jewell's departure, at least for now. They deservesomecredit after ponying up to extendWRs Ja'Marr Chase, who was the league's top-paid non-quarterback for a few months, and Tee Higgins, a development that kept QB Joe Burrow happy. But, at least in regard to Chase, an All-Pro who won the league's receiving triple crown in 2024, that was a no-brainer … as it was last year, when he would have cost significantly less. One would also think giving All-Pro DE Trey Hendricksonthe raise he's earnedgoing into the last year of his contract, or even simply signing first-round DE Shemar Stewart wouldsimilarly be no-brainers. But the Bengals have been Bengal-ing and risk immediately crippling their season at its outset if Hendrickson and Stewart, who's impressive skill set already needed polishing, remain absent from what's already a highly suspect defense. They'll likely need to rely even more on their top two draft picks, RB Omarion Hampton and WR Tre Harris,following the July 4 eye injurysufferedby RB Najee Harris, a free agent pickup, and WR Mike Williams,who decided to retire last week. (Good thing the Bolts drafted with a sense of redundance.) Beyond that, they hung on to OLB Khalil Mack but let Bosa go. The Chargers' two other biggest additions were Becton and CB Donte Jackson. Meh. Despite Harbaugh's optimism, tight end, corner and maybe even who will be QB Justin Herbert's top pass-catching alternative to WR Ladd McConkey remain concerns. LT Rashawn Slater still needs a new contract. Unlike the Vikings, they haven't been able to optimize the supporting cast around QB Michael Penix Jr., who enters a season as the starter for the first time, because he's got a backup, Kirk Cousins, with a nine-figure contract. And now he'll loom over Penix from the sideline while hovering like a dark cloud over the salary cap. GM Terry Fontenot did manage to extend LT Jake Matthews but couldn't hang on to promising Dalman. Jarrett also left for Chicago. Maybe Fontenot will get more from a notoriously underwhelming pass rush after signing Floyd and drafting Jalon Walker and James Pearce in Round 1, though Pearce came at the exorbitantly high cost of next year's first-round pick. As Brad Pitt's "F1" character, Sonny Hayes, said: "Hope is not a strategy." But kinda feels like that's where the Colts are as they assess whether Anthony Richardson or Daniel Jones will be their Week 1 quarterback – an issue potentially exacerbated after the offensive line was raided during free agency. First-round TE Tyler Warren projects as an immediate difference maker. Sadly, much will be different in these parts for an organizationrocked by the recent deathof longtime owner Jim Irsay. For those who see water in the glass,DE Aidan Hutchinson is on track to returnfrom the broken leg that prematurely ended a 2024 season in which he seemed destined to win Defensive Player of the Year honors. All-Pro Kerby Joseph also became the league's highest-paid safety with a four-year, $86 million extension. But the injury bug also got an extension, DT Levi Onwuzurike already lost to a season-ending knee injury, and DT Alim McNeill still recovering from a torn ACL. C Frank Ragnow belatedly chose retirementover another season of pain. Rookie DL Tyleik Williams and OL Tate Radledge will need to be ready to play straight away. LB Alex Anzalone also seems to have some wounded pride as he awaits an extension heading into his walk year. But the main issue for this team, which is a bit of a victim of its own recent success, could be the departure of eight assistants, most notably OC Ben Johnson (Bears) and DC Glenn (Jets), both hired to their first head coaching gigs. A team that's gone 27-7 over the past two regular seasons will be severely challenged to maintain its momentum, much less build on it. A team that's been unable to win games of importance in recent years has been hemorrhaging talent, LT Terron Armstead retiring, Holland leaving during free agency, then Ramsey and Jonnu Smith traded last month. WR Tyreek Hill admits he's (still) working on his professionalism. Maybe first-round DT Kenneth Grant and second-round G Jonah Savaiinaea will provide toughness some have said this team lacks. GM Chris Grier and HC Mike McDaniel don't seem all that well positioned to justify the vote of confidence owner Stephen Ross gave the after last season's 8-9 finish. Theyseemto be playing something of a long game, but it's just too early to know how it ultimately plays out as a team likely destined to finish last in the AFC North straddles the line between rebuilding and trying to remain competitive. They compelled DE Myles Garrett to stick around after making him the first non-QB with a contract averaging $40 million annually (over 4 years). Whether Cleveland should have cashed out on a 29-year-old at the peak of his powers who'd requested a trade earlier in the year remains an open question. After all, the Browns divested the No. 2 overall pick of the draft for a package that included Jacksonville's first-rounder next year. So what are we doing? TBD, which also sums up the team's four-way competition to determine its starting quarterback, a scrum that includes former Super Bowl MVP Joe Flacco andfifth-round lightning rod Shedeur Sanders. Otherwise? Though GM Andrew Berry passed on the opportunity to pick Hunter, he brought in some very nice players, including DT Mason Graham, LB Carson Schwesinger and battering ram RB Quinshon Judkins – though his availability is currently in limbo after he was recently charged with misdemeanor domestic battery. Pro Bowl LB Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah (neck) is already out for the year. But hey, y'all, the team could be playing in a fancy new stadium in four years … a point when we'll know whether keeping Garrett, bypassing Hunter and picking Judkins and Sanders while likely punting on a long-term quarterback solution until 2026 were wise decisions. All NFL news on and off the field.Sign upfor USA TODAY's 4th and Monday newsletter. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY:NFL grades: Training camps open, offseason report cards for each team
With training camps open, time to grade every NFL team's offseason – just two get A's The NFL offseason, such as it is, officially e...
